The Good Place spoilers up to S2E06
So I’m very happy that the plot is currently following what I saw as the most viable and interesting path, bettering the protagonists rather than submitting them to eternal torment. I did not expect Michael to be included in the package in their little asylum plan, however, and watching him trying to grasp ethics is both hilarious and moving. My husband thinks Michael is the protagonist of Season 2 where Eleanor was the protagonist of Season 1, and so far the season seems to validate him. If that’s the schema of these seasons I wonder who’d be the protagonist in Season 3. I hope it’s Chidi, in conjunction with real-time (and not surreptitiously videotaped by a creepy coke addict) Eleanor/Chidi. Theirs is one of the most endearing slow burns I’ve seen in a while, and they are both hilarious and heartwarming together.
I loved the idea of Tahani/Jianyu from the first, too, and Tahani/Jason makes even more sense in a weird kind of way. Now let’s see if it actually lasts. I’m still 50/50 on Jason finding out he was married to Janet and going back to her, but I hope he and Tahani last because they are so different and yet get along so well together. While both my husband and I swore out loud when Jason proposed, I can also understand him here. He’s had so little stability in his life and people to hold onto, so I can see why he would make an impulsive proposal when he sees a chance at that. And I don’t think it’s technically bigamy? My very own Florida Man heartthrob, I just want him to be happy. He’s my favorite bro character since Josh Chan from Crazy Ex Girlfriend, and the character is getting a whole lot more respect than Josh which is great.
On to more cerebral matters, I not only respect Michael’s thinking out of the box, I think his idea inevitably sprouted the seeds of reformation over punishment. (God, those Criminal Law and Criminal Policy classes from 20 years ago…) His method was tailored specifically to the prisoners’ lives, and the psychological torture forced them to reflect back on their vanities, hypocricies, and hurtful actions in life more effectively than butt spiders ever did. The nature of the punishment also gave the prisoners, especially Eleanor, something to aspire to–the vision of heaven, and also her friends imperfect as they may be. That’s way more clever and meaningful than an eternity of sadistic, gleeful torture. It may not have been Michael’s original intent to induce self-reflection and growth, but that was the result precisely because he devised a better punishment than the way Hell had been doing things.
My current theory is that this is exactly what the hitherto-unseen denizens of The Good Place intended. I think the endgame of the angels, gods, bodhisavattas, administrators or whatnot that are in charge TGP is for everyone to learn to be better and come to Paradise, and Michael’s scheme is just the foot in the door they needed and wanted. I think they wanted him to take a Good Place Janet, too, to build a more convincing Good Place neighborhood and for him to learn the value of selfless service and friendship.
One twist I’d love is if Michael is actually the origin story of the Archangel Michael. I mean that’s who I thought he was back when I thought he was an angel, and what’s a little thing like sequential time to transcendent beings?