I’ll forever be salty that by judging from the set photos of Finn in a Cobalt flight suit, Rian denied Finn having a new healthy squad in TLJ. He just really hates Finn.

Having Finn be a part of Cobalt Squadron would not only have helped him develop a more organic relationship with the Resistance, something like the Cobalt Squadron book would have given him a much better window into the suffering of the larger galaxy under the First Order than the Canto Bight arc would have. It would even have been a better setup for Finnrose. But nah, RJ just didn’t feel like writing all that because he can’t be arsed to do the job he was contracted to do where Finn was involved.

Why did Chris Evans quit?

He had decided on this move a long time ago and had announced it as far back as 2014 (link). Avengers 4 was always going to be his last MCU movie. He didn’t want to become stale in the role–“You want to get off the train before they push you off,“ in his words–and he has wanted for years to do more directing and producing. Being in a huge franchise like Marvel helped launch him into more opportunities, but the schedule didn’t allow him to commit himself to roles behind the camera. This was a long-planned career move on his part and I wish him well.

Do you have any fave SW fanfics where POC are the main characters?

I haven’t been reading a lot of fanfic in general and the few I do read are generally Finnrey, but the list of Finnpoe fanfics will probably fit the bill (link).

Though short pieces, I have also written non-Finnrey fics that prominently feature Finn and other characters of color.

  • Eggshells: A short story inspired by @vague-humanoid‘s ask about Finn and lying. A little bit Finnrey but mostly about Finn’s psychology, arguing that the ability to hide himself and lie was empowering and humanizing for Finn in an environment where his every move was controlled.
  • An untitled piece of speculation/headcanon/fanfic about how Poe’s father Kes might react to Poe’s torture in TFA.
    • Another untitled piece following up from the above, this time in more traditional fiction format, about Kes and Finn discussing Finn’s trauma post-TLJ. It has a little Finnpoe as well.
  • Free: Done for the Day 1 prompt of @finnappreciationweek, this is a solo Finn piece looking at his TFA arc and start of TLJ.
  • Running like Mandalorians: This one’s about Force-sensitive warriors Mandalorian Finn and Boba Fett fighting bad guys. It’s set in my alternate SW sequel trilogy.
  • Don’t Stop: A Finnrose fanfic back before TLJ when I was actually excited about Finnrose.

I just saw a Ro Laren gifset and it reminded me of something I never understood. There was tension between the Bajoran Resistance and the Maquis. I don’t understand why Bajorans like Ro didn’t resign their commissions with Starfleet to join the Resistance and chose to join the Maquis instead. I remember Kira saying that the Maquis were only angry that the Federation has to make concessions to end the war with the Cardassians and they didn’t care about the Occupation.

Ro seems to have had a complicated relationship with her heritage from early on since she left Bajor out of a sense of shame at her own people, though she rethought this later on when she decided to use her name in its Bajoran form and wear the distinctive earring. From her Memory Alpha description it seems to me that her decision to join the Maquis was more because of her growing attachment to the particular cell she was sent to infiltrate than political belief in the Maquis’ cause (other than the fighting Cardassians part). To me she reads as someone who was looking for something to replace a severed sense of belonging, not someone who was firmly rooted in her Bajoran identity like Kira. While Ro was far from the only Bajoran Maquis fighter, the Maquis do seem to have been made up mostly of settlers of the worlds the Federation ceded to the Cardassians and their sympathizers, not driven primarily by Bajorans.

I keep trying to remind myself that most comments on the reddit post are actually either people who agree or respectfully disagree and try to appreciate his arc for what it is (overall supportive). And those are the most upvoted as well as opposed to the pure bashing/racism that’re mostly negative voted or removed. But hate it just always so much louder.

Ehh, idk about that when the first reply on the thread, one of the highest voted, says in part:

Finn was always meant to be a secondary rather than primary hero
regardless of who was cast to play him, and his personal journey, when
it didn’t coincide with Rey’s, was always going to be the B-plot to her
(and eventually Kylo’s) A-plot.

Stuff like this is just a more polite version of some of the worse comments that @diversehighfantasy​ highlighted (link), and it can be as disheartening to Black fans as the crass comments while having enough of a sheen of respectability so that people feel comfortable agreeing and responding positively to it. I don’t see how racism is any better if it’s genteel and polite.

I think the difference between how the right and left see race is individualist vs collectivist. The right believes only individuals, not demographics, are superior to others, and that privilege is fluid. That’s how the American dream works (even though when the American dream was first envisioned, it did only apply to white people, but aside from that…) In theory, individualism cannot be racist because color is irrelevant, but in practice it doesn’t always work that way.

For example, the valid concern that diversity quotas value color
over merit is valid, but can skip into the bias that white people are
the most qualified. And the concern that racism against white people is
culturally acceptable is a rational concern, but then there are white
supremacists who equate it with genocide.

In conclusion, it is my personal conviction that untainted
individualism is they key to being unracist. Everybody respect Muslims
and people of Middle Eastern descent, ship Finnrey, and recognize that
Rogue One is not anti-white because it only has one white male hero
(Galen.)


So there’s a lot to unpack here, but first of all, it’s a false dichotomy that the right believes in individual merit and the left doesn’t. What many on the left do is acknowledge the reality that bigotry against certain groups cuts against the merits and achievements of individuals from these marginalized groups. I’m not sure how that translates into the kind of collectivism that is apparently opposed to individualism. Also if you think the only problem with the American dream lies in the distant past… well. Let’s just say it’s very much an ongoing problem.

At least you recognize the gap between theory and practice when it comes to individualism. In fact, talent and work ethic leading to success is far from the reality for many groups, to the extent that believing that individual merit will prevail in every case has been found to be detrimental to the long-term well-being of marginalized youth (link).

Colorblindness is the ultimate aspiration, yes, but it is not the reality we currently inhabit. We can’t just decide to be colorblind, we have to acknowledge and correct the systemic racism that both leads to large-scale inequalities and infects our own individual perceptions with bias and bigotry. Insisting that you are colorblind without realizing all the ways you are not amounts to self-deception and, in interactions with marginalized people, gaslighting. We don’t get to the mountaintop by pretending we are already there. First we have to realize where we actually are, which is a pretty deep pit in many ways. Only then can we start climbing upward.

Capri Sun’s official twitter account is run by reylos. Chance the Rapper is a reylo. Niki Minaj or one of the Kardashians (IDK) made a tweet defending Ben Solo. Fact is: Reylo’s THE popular ship of the ST & I don’t like it. Lucasfilms will probably think that they scared everyone off with episode VIII & that the only group of people that will sit themselves in the theater will be reylos. I really hope that it doesn’t happen, I don’t want Ben in the Falcon after what he did but he probably will.

So you claim not to like Reylow but you come up with all these obscure examples that only Reylows really care about and keep calling Kylo Ren “Ben.” Talk about an identification and tone mismatch. Kylo Ren flying the Millennium Falcon is another reylow wet dream that nobody else cares about. If you’re going to be in my inbox at least send me honest anon hate instead of going for these weirdo psy-ops, okay? You’re not very good at it.