You’re rebooting a billion-dollar film franchise with new young leads and you’ve convinced the older cast members to return. You create a leading woman character and include a ~mystery~ about what her family origins are.
Who have you secretly written for her father?
A. Iconic character from the original franchise; also the ‘MacGuffin’ of of your new film. He meets your leading woman at the end in a wordless, emotionally charged moment.
B. Iconic character from the original franchise; he spends time with your leading woman and, in spite of his gruff exterior, cares about her well-being enough to offer her a chance to escape her difficult circumstances.
C. Iconic character from the original and sequel franchise; he died years before your leading woman was born, so either he’s not the father or you have to write some mumbo-jumbo to make him fit that role. There’s no reference to him in the film other than the first given name of the man who kills character B.
D. IDK, just some random dude.
B. Had so much rapport with her the two of them finished each other’s sentences, and shared the love of the ship that is all but synonymous with him. He was described as “the father [she] never had,” was perhaps “more grateful than anyone” that she was safe, was murdered before her eyes in a setup that would create incredible drama if he is her father.
C. Can only be her grandfather due to the dates, and the father or mother would be a character from an animated series which the vast majority of the audience have never seen and have no reason to care about.
On the choice of mothers you have:
A. A random lady who will have to be another absent/dead mother or be built up from the second movie onward on top of everything else that’s going on.
B. Iconic character from the original and sequel franchise; an indomitable, beloved heroine for decades both in-universe and in the real world who would have memorable mother-daughter interactions with the heroine and be the linchpin of a heartrending family drama.
C. Another random lady
D. Yet another random lady